Today's issue of San Jose's The Mercury News ran an op-ed by Harvey Mudd President Maria Klawe.
After decrying the poor state of mathematics education in America and reminding us of the post -Sputnik generation, Klawe writes in favor of Math for America, an expanding program in the New York and soon the Los Angeles public schools. Math for America Los Angeles will be operated by Harvey Mudd College, Claremont Graduate University and the University of Southern California. No word yet on when it will begin.
Math for America focuses on recruiting, training and rewarding teachers who specialize in teaching mathematics. Currently in New York, 100 MfA fellows and master teachers teach in 60 public schools, and by 2011, MfA will support at least 440 teachers. The program offers a stipend to fellows that supplements their salary and ensures they earn amounts comparable to other professionals with similar levels of education and training.
On the one hand, I rather like the idea of giving merit money to competent teachers. (My mother is a teacher and I sure appreciate trickle down economics.) I've always wondered why it is that we give combat pay to soldiers and not to some of the teachers working in the inner-city.
Still I question how that money is going to be spent and how it will affect teacher retention in the inner city. The stipend, according to Math for America's website, is only $90,000 for five years. Afterwards, the teachers presumably go back to getting paid the same as their peers.
After all, as Klawe probably knows, the per student expenditure in American public school education is among the highest.
What's more, this program may be poorly targeted. Public school teachers in the inner-city don't quit because of the pay. In fact, most inner city public school teachers make much more
than their suburban counterparts due in no small part to the power of the inner-city teachers' unions.
Teachers quit for all sorts of reasons: lack of gifted and talented programs for high achieving students and teachers, lack of administration and parents support, and lack of protection from gang activities. Teachers are often the victim of crimes, something no amount of money will help. In a phrase, teachers are simply burned out. No amount of money is going to change that. If anything, it may only create dependency.
I share Klawe's dream of another post-Sputnik generation, but we've first got to get our head out of the clouds.